Citizen Science

Critiquing the Role of the Citizen Scientist

The role of the citizen scientist is certainly still an evolving one, and will likely eternally be in flux. Before the era of professional scientists comfortably sitting at respected universities and industrial businesses, which is now commonplace, the majority of scientific exploration was accomplished by the non-professional, or “natural philosopher”. In fact, the term “scientist” wasn’t even used until William Whewell coined the term in 1833. These days, not everyone can–nor should–follow a career path into professional research, but there is no reason why someone interested in learning about and even participating in scientific exploration should be excluded from the opportunities.

There is certainly a difference between data processors and pure scientists. One person plugs and chugs through data using a pre-defined set of rules and regulations. The other actually develops those rules, thoroughly thinks about how to use them, and makes conclusions about the results with skill. But, the inherent sensation in this comparison–that one somehow is less interesting than the other–misses the real purpose and excitement of citizen science efforts.

We certainly don’t need everyone to be converted into fundamental science researchers to profess at ivy league institutions. There are certainly many of them out there already, and the job market these days for new hires offers some slim pickings. The point, rather, of citizen science is to inspire and generate a broad appreciation for science and the universe in which we live.

Involving a wider spectrum of the population with accessible, fun, and interesting projects–even if they “only” require human-level data processing, which, by the way, in the realm of pattern recognition, is still so much more impressive than computer-based data processing!–can only positively support everyone involved. In addition, a culture with a greater population who has increased levels of science appreciation will also benefit in long-term sustainability, assuming you believe that a more clear understanding of science across the majority of individuals can only bring about good things.

So, although the “crowd sourcing” and citizen science projects in effect right now (GalaxyZoo being a primary example) might not require each participant to be a full-scale experimentalist, it seems like absolutely nothing is lost. If fact, it seems that because of this non-requirement, even more is gained for the larger picture, since the hurdles for participation are not insurmountable for nearly everyone.

The more non-professionals involved in doing real science–even if it is “just” data processing–will bring a greater appreciation to these non-professionals, which will only help support the professionals down the road (say, through successful data analysis resulting in new discoveries, or the increased willingness of citizens to pay those higher tax dollars into the NSF and NIH).

“Citizen Science Isn’t Enough Science For Citizens” :: Michael White’s Adaptive Complexity, Science 2.0 :: June 8, 2010 :: [READ]

“Experts Weigh in on Crowd Science Trend” :: genomeWeb’s The Daily Scan :: June 4, 2010 :: [READ]

“The Growth of ‘Citizen Science'” :: The Chronicle of Higher Education :: June 3, 2010 :: [READ]

Critiquing the Role of the Citizen Scientist Read More »

NPR Features Citizen Scientist

This weekend’s All Things Considered from NPR featured a professional astronomer turned bold citizen scientist who is building a satellite to convert the Earth’s magnetic field high in the ionosphere into MIDI music.

DPR featured Alex Antunes in September 2009 (read more), and we are excited to update that his notice is growing into a public, national audience. Dr. Antunes is also a key contributor on Science 2.0, and you may also stay updated with his progress on his Project Calliope site.

“DIY Satellites Let You Find Your Own Space” :: NPR All Things Considered with Audie Cornish :: July 24, 2010 :: [ READ ]

NPR Features Citizen Scientist Read More »

Mars as Big as the Moon… this year only! (and next year, and the next)

Painted green by a flashlight, astronomer Dennis Mammana of California points out Mars to onlookers on Aug. 26, 2003, when Mars was particularly close to Earth. Photo credit: Thad V'Soske via NASA Science

Mars came particularly close to Earth back in 2003, and ever since we have been experiencing an annual email hoax convincing us that we will once again have a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to see Mars as big as the Moon.

The cycle is happing again (view an interactive orbit map), with an expected closer encounter to happen this August. However, when you look up into the sky next month, you won’t see the Moon and the Red Planet together as temporary twins.

The close approach that occurred on August 27, 2003 was indeed the most near we have been to Mars in some 60,000 years. And, we are talking only 56 million kilometers (about 34.8 million miles) close. Take an important comparative note here that the Moon sits anywhere between about 363,000 and 406,000 km from Earth (learn more about the Moon). However, near approaches have routinely happened many times in between 58,000 B.C. and 2003, with more recent occurrences in 1845 and 1924, which were only around 50 thousand km less. Not so much difference in the scale of the Solar System.

What’s great about this particular hoax is that it is a perfect opportunity for citizen scientists to learn (or re-learn) about planetary orbits, and to help spread the excitement about the real physics of our Solar System. It is truly incredible that all of these massive objects are spinning around in such predictable harmony, and that anyone can discover so much information about how it all works.

For example, NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory provides an online system, called JPL HORIZONS, for reporting the ephemeris (positions of astronomical bodies) for planets, planetary satellites, spacecraft, and other dynamic points throughout or Solar System. The distances can also be calculated to your personal location on Earth from anytime since January 4, 1900 up through January 3, 2100.

So, watch your email inbox carefully over the next several weeks (and make sure you don’t download any computer viruses), and help your friends learn more about the reality of our planetary neighbor Mars, since you–or your children–might travel there someday!

“Mars Spectacular” from Snopes.com :: [ READ HOAX Report ]

“Beware the Mars Hoax” :: Science@NASA :: July 7, 2005 :: [ READ ]

Powerpoint Presentation via Email Hoax received by DPR  :: Mars is So Close Hoax

Interactive Mars-Earth-Sun Orbit Map [ TRY IT ]
from Windows to the Universe (requires Flash)
Try running the simulation backwards to August 27, 2003 and see how close Mars really was.
How close was Mars on your birth date?

JPL HORIZONS Ephemeris Calculation System [ TRY IT ]

Mars as Big as the Moon… this year only! (and next year, and the next) Read More »

Extreme Amateur Science: Building the Sun in your Basement

Mark Suppes' Fusion Reactor

In 2008, DPR discussed the emergence of an extreme case of amateur research [READ more] where a growing number of independent citizens (see the list) are developing working fusion reactors at home.

There must be an emphasis on the extreme here as a citizen science project, since the financial requirements are high (an understatement, for sure). Although the actual process of low-scale fusion in a properly sealed chamber is reasonably safe (in particular, there is low radiation and no nasty nuclear waste left over to throw away), high voltages are required and an advanced technical flair must be developed.

A fusion reaction occurs when two similar light weight atoms are brought together under high temperature and high pressure, slam together, and re-form as a single atom. Energy is released from the process … a lot of energy … and efficiently harnessing the outgoing energy has been a holy-grail project of physicists for more than a half-century. This is the energy process that powers our Sun. And it has been efficiently glowing for some time now.

One of the key challenges is that it takes more energy to generate the fusion reaction in the laboratory than what you can extract, which doesn’t make so much economic sense for the utility industry.

So, the primary goal of institution researchers — and of the amateurs — is to design and create a functioning “break-even” fusion reactor, where you harvest the same amount of energy that you put into the system. Success here still would not be the end-game, but it is a goal that seems to be reasonable for reaching in the near future.

The ultimate payoff here, of course, is so incredible and is becoming more desired every day (see all that sludge sloshing toward the gulf coast line?). No large-scale carbon emissions. No politically- and environmentally-threatening nuclear waste. No sloppy oily deposits. Just clean, beautifully-glowing plasma to bring slick and fast electricity to satisfy all of our energy-hungry lives.

If you have the cash, you might try converting your garage to a fusion reaction laboratory. The entire human population on Planet Earth would be grateful.

“Extreme DIY: Building a homemade nuclear reactor in NYC” :: BBC News, Matthew Danzico :: June 23, 2010 :: [ READ with Video ]

Mark Suppes Blog about his Prometheus Fusion Reactor [ VISIT ]

The Open Source Fusor Research Consortium [ VISIT ]

Learn more about fusion from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory [ VISIT ]

UPDATE July 25, 2010:
Tip Sheet for Inertial Electrostatic Confinement Fusion Investigators, by Tom Ligon, from fusor.net :: [ DOWNLOA PDF ]

Extreme Amateur Science: Building the Sun in your Basement Read More »

Amateur Photographer Masters the Snapshot of a Firefly

from Terry Priest Firefly Photography

Fireflies have been flashing into a broader public awareness lately, well beyond those simple childhood summer evening memories of running through the yard capturing these little creatures into temporary glass prisons.

In particular, the Firefly Watch program from Boston’s Museum of Science (read DPR’s review from 2008) has been bringing more people together across the country to measure current back-yard populations of fire flies. Their numbers seem to be declining significantly in recent years, and the researchers guiding this great citizen science program hope to find out why our flashy little friends aren’t as happy these days.

An amateur photographer from Evansville, Indiana has helped to glorify and beautify the bug by developing his own process for creating incredible still images of fire flies in action. Terry Priest started generating successful photographs using a typical hand-held four mega-pixel digital camera, and has advanced into more sophisticated equipment, including high-speed flashes.

And, his images are breathtaking. And, you can create similarly breathtaking images yourself in your own backyard… tonight. Mr. Priest has written a detailed online guidance on how to craft these images, and he hopes that his efforts will inspire other amateur photographers to explore the life of the flashing bug.

“Terry Priest photographs fireflies in flight” :: Evansville Courier and Press :: July 11, 2010
[ READ ]

[ View ] Terry Priest’s Flikr photostream

Terry Priest’s Tutorial on Photographing the Firefly [ READ ]

Amateur Photographer Masters the Snapshot of a Firefly Read More »

European Amateur Science Society Makes Major Dinosaur Discovery

For several years, a European amateur science group was on the trail of dinosaur prints and last spring they made a significant discovery. Now authenticated by scientists at Lyon University and France’s National Center for Scientific Research, the find is one of the largest and most well preserved prints from a sauropod estimated to be 150 million years old.

What’s particularly exciting about this finding–in addition to the pure excitement from being able to directly witness the movements of our planet’s once great giants–is that the possibility of important scientific progress coming from groups of amateurs and citizen scientists is so great. More organized citizen scientist groups must be developed around the world, and with this growth not only will scientific progress benefit, but the increased appreciation and understanding of science will begin to reach an even broader population.

For example, in the United States, the Society of Amateur Scientists is a national organization that will support the development of local and regional chapters, which is the absolute perfect opportunity for interested people to self-organize and generate some real science and generate some real science appreciation for the masses. Their current list of active local chapters is rather limited, but the time is ripe for growing local interest and regional society groups to become deeply involved in citizen science around the country.

In particular, this author is working on establishing a local chapter for the Central Illinois region, so if you are located in the area and would be interested in considering being a charter member of a new local chapter, please let me know.

Be inspired by the increasing number of successes of important results from citizen scientists and get more involved to see what wonderful science you may discover and experience.

“”Unique” dinosaur footprints discovered in France” :: Reuters / AP :: October 6, 2009 :: [ READ ]

European Amateur Science Society Makes Major Dinosaur Discovery Read More »

Last updated June 20, 2022